Articles Tagged with “Prejudicial Evidence”

Published on:

It is rare and wonderful to see an entrapment opinion. And United States v. Kopstein fits the bill.

To the victories!

1155650_berlin_siegessule.jpg1. United States v. Kopstein, Second Circuit: Appellant was convicted by a jury of transporting and shipping child pornography. During trial, Appellant’s sole defense was entrapment. The conviction was vacated and the case remanded because the jury instruction on entrapment failed to consistently and adequately guide the jury. Here, a jury instruction on the lesser-included offense of possession would allow the jury to return a verdict of guilty on the transporting and shipping charge, even if the jury found Appellant not guilty of possession. This was confusing because it would allow the jury to render a verdict of guilty on the greater offense even if the prosecution had failed to prove a necessary part of its case (the lesser offense).

Published on:

In a classic Simpsons episode, Homer Simpson, as a young person, is excluded from a club of his peers – the club is called the “No Homers Club.” Homer complains, noting that there was a Homer inside the clubhouse.

He’s told – “It says no Homers. We’re allowed to have one.” (Incidentally, the “No Homers Club” is now the name of many Simpsons fan clubs).

DSC01433_z.JPGClub rules tend, I think, to be silly. The Seventh Circuit’s recent opinion in United States v. Loughry however, meant the difference in whether a child pornography conviction stands can depend on the rules of a private “club.”